The JurnalPkM (Jurnal PkM Pemberdayaan Masyarakat) is committed to maintaining high standards of publication quality and academic integrity. Every submitted manuscript undergoes a rigorous, fair, and transparent evaluation process before publication.
The peer review process consists of the following stages:
-
1. Initial Editorial Screening (Desk Evaluation) Upon submission, the handling editor evaluates the manuscript for:
-
Alignment with the journal's Focus and Scope.
-
Adherence to the journal's Author Guidelines and template formatting.
-
Plagiarism check using professional software (e.g., Turnitin). Manuscripts exceeding the maximum allowable similarity threshold or lacking academic novelty are rejected at this stage.
-
-
2. Double-Blind Peer Review Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to at least two independent peer reviewers (Mitra Bestari) who are experts in fields related to community service and the manuscript's topic.
-
To ensure objectivity, the journal implements a double-blind review policy: the identities of both the authors and the reviewers remain anonymous to each other.
-
-
3. Review Criteria Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on several key dimensions:
-
Relevance and Impact: Practical significance of the community service activity, community engagement level, and sustainability of outcomes.
-
Methodology: Appropriateness of the community empowerment methods, problem-solving framework, and implementation steps.
-
Results and Discussion: Clarity in presenting implementation outcomes, beneficiary changes, and alignment with theoretical frameworks.
-
Presentation Quality: Clarity of writing, logical flow, and accurate referencing.
-
-
4. Editorial Decision Based on the reviewers' recommendations, the editor makes one of the following decisions:
-
Accepted: The manuscript is ready for publication without major changes.
-
Minor Revisions: The author is requested to make small corrections or address minor comments within a specified timeframe.
-
Major Revisions: The manuscript requires substantial revisions regarding analysis, discussion, or structure, and will typically be re-evaluated by the reviewers.
-
Rejected: The manuscript is unsuitable for publication due to critical flaws in scope, methodology, or quality.
-
-
5. Final Decision and Production The Editor-in-Chief makes the final acceptance decision based on the revised manuscript and the reviewers' final feedback, followed by copyediting, layout formatting, and online publication.